How each list is checked
Order and years
For every series the order and the year of each book are taken from one named list, currently the series list in the relevant Wikipedia article. A copy of that article is kept exactly as it was fetched, and the build of this site stops if any title, year or position on a page cannot be found in that copy in the same sequence.
What Open Library is used for
The year printed for each book is always the first-publication year from the order source. Open Library, a catalogue run by the Internet Archive, is used for something narrower: to confirm the book is catalogued, and to show the earliest edition it lists. It never replaces the year.
Each book is matched by exact title against Open Library's list of the author's works. If more than 3 works share the title, we cannot tell which one is the book, and the list says how many works carry that title and that none was matched. Otherwise the work with the most editions is used. If two or more works tie for the most editions, the list says how many equally likely records there are and that they were not compared. If the work used has fewer than 10 editions, the list says how many editions Open Library lists and that they were not compared. If none of its editions carries a year, the list says "Open Library lists no edition year". If no work in the author's list carries the exact title, we check by hand whether Open Library lists the book under a title that differs in one way only: a bracketed series name and book number added at the end, such as "New Spring (The Wheel of Time, Book 0)"; a leading "The" left off; or only the part before a colon. If so, that work is used under the same rules as above, and the list adds "Listed in Open Library as" followed by Open Library's title word for word. If not, the list says "Open Library lists no work under this exact title". We do not fill a missing year from anywhere else.
For the rest, we read every edition of that work and take the earliest year that appears in its publication date. When that year matches, the list says so and links the edition. When it is later, the list says "Open Library's earliest listed edition is later" and gives that year. When it is earlier than the first edition, the list says "Earliest Open Library record predates first edition" and links that edition; Open Library does not say why the record carries the earlier year. The year kept is the first-publication year in each case.
Open Library check: Game of Thrones
Each book in the Game of Thrones list, looked up in Open Library under the rules above. Each year links to that edition's record.
| # | Title | First published (Wikipedia) | Earliest edition listed in Open Library | Result |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | A Game of Thrones | 1996 | 1996 | Same year |
| 2 | A Clash of Kings | 1998 | 1998 | Same year |
| 3 | A Storm of Swords | 2000 | 2000 | Same year |
| 4 | A Feast for Crows | 2005 | 2005 | Same year |
| 5 | A Dance with Dragons | 2011 | Earliest Open Library record predates first edition | Wikipedia year kept |
Open Library check: The Chronicles of Narnia
Each book in the The Chronicles of Narnia list, looked up in Open Library under the rules above. Each year links to that edition's record.
| # | Title | First published (Wikipedia) | Earliest edition listed in Open Library | Result |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | The Lion, the Witch and the Wardrobe | 1950 | Open Library has 9 works with this title; none was matched | Not compared |
| 2 | Prince Caspian | 1951 | Open Library has 21 works with this title; none was matched | Not compared |
| 3 | The Voyage of the Dawn Treader | 1952 | Open Library has 13 works with this title; none was matched | Not compared |
| 4 | The Silver Chair | 1953 | Open Library has 6 works with this title; none was matched | Not compared |
| 5 | The Horse and His Boy | 1954 | 1954 | Same year |
| 6 | The Magician's Nephew | 1955 | Open Library has 4 works with this title; none was matched | Not compared |
| 7 | The Last Battle | 1956 | Open Library has 5 works with this title; none was matched | Not compared |
Open Library check: Dune
Each book in the Dune list, looked up in Open Library under the rules above. Each year links to that edition's record.
| # | Title | First published (Wikipedia) | Earliest edition listed in Open Library | Result |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Dune | 1965 | Open Library has 4 works with this title; none was matched | Not compared |
| 2 | Dune Messiah | 1969 | 1969 | Same year |
| 3 | Children of Dune | 1976 | 1976 | Same year |
| 4 | God Emperor of Dune | 1981 | 1981 | Same year |
| 5 | Heretics of Dune | 1984 | 1984 | Same year |
| 6 | Chapterhouse: Dune | 1985 | 1985 | Same year |
Other titles and notes
If a book was sold under another name somewhere, that name appears only when a source says so in words, and those words are quoted on the page. The same goes for notes on a series, such as where prequels fit or how later editions renumbered the books: they are quoted word for word from the order source, and the build stops if the quotation cannot be found in the saved copy.
What is left out
No cover art, posters or film stills, and no plot summaries. Lists keep to the titles a source counts as part of the series; spin-offs, companion books and stage plays are named as outside the list rather than mixed in. We do not publish a suggested reading order unless an author or publisher has set one out.
Sources used so far
Wikipedia text is reused under CC BY-SA 4.0 with a link to the revision that was read. Open Library data is released under CC0.
Typefaces
Headings use Libre Caslon Text (Copyright 2012 The Libre Caslon Text Project Authors) and body text uses Outfit (Copyright 2021 The Outfit Project Authors). Both typefaces are free fonts, released with version 1.1 of the SIL Open Font License: Libre Caslon Text licence, Outfit licence.